Free or not free, that is the, er, question

A forum for discussing world news, ideas, concepts and possibly controversial topics including religion and politics. WARNING: may contain strong opinions or strong language. This does not mean anything goes though!
Forum rules
Please read the Forum rules and policies before posting.
Post Reply
Guest

Free or not free, that is the, er, question

Post by Guest »

Hi,

First post on this forum, only just found it, but since I was always a huge fan of DM and its sequels it is good to see so many fellow fans :)

Appologies if this question has been asked before, I'm sure it has, but I couldn't find it posted on this forum anywhere...

My question is this, I know DM, CSB (etc) are downloadable from a site who's URL is posted often on this forum. However, the site makes no mention of copyright issues, and I'm sure someone somewhere owns the rights, so surely this isn't legal? Unless perhaps you own original copies?

I used to own original copies back when they came out. But my old amiga died beyond repair many years ago and I threw it out (I know, stupid) and have since got rid of all my old games... The only thing I can think to do is hunt down second hand copies, which if I then own I presume means its okay to download the emulator copies...

Any advice gratefully received,

Cheers

Oid
User avatar
Paul Stevens
CSBwin Guru
Posts: 4318
Joined: Sun Apr 08, 2001 6:00 pm
Location: Madison, Wisconsin, USA

Post by Paul Stevens »

I think pretty much all of us own original copies
of the program. I have an Atari DM, a PC DM and DMII,
and I have two Atari CSBs. It seems that the only
people interested are those who discovered these
games long, long ago and therefore had original copies
at one time. Having had a copy and thrown it away
may not make it strictly legal but it passes my
reasonableness test.
User avatar
beowuuf
Archmastiff
Posts: 20687
Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2000 2:00 pm
Location: Basingstoke, UK

Post by beowuuf »

Legal, no.
There seems to be a certain knowledge of the existence of this community, clones, etc by people with the copyrights and no one has been procecuted, so make of it as you what you will, but it should be possible to find original versions on e-bay, etc if you want a clear conscience
User avatar
cowsmanaut
Moo Master
Posts: 4378
Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2000 12:53 am
Location: canada

Post by cowsmanaut »

let us put it this way. Were you to buy a second hand copy of DM or CSB the creators would get as much money from that as you downloading it from here. It's not sold any more so their is no loss of income. Nothing to chase after.

Is it technically legal to do this? No. However, it is not as if the copyright holders are not aware of what is going on. As said the majority of us who are seeking the game have made our contribution to FTL by buying the games the first time around. Some of us still have the Disks (like me) some of us simply threw them away when their compter died.

I certainly think it Fair that if you've paid for it at some point you be allowed to play it again without having to pay for it again. Though everquest fans may dissagree since they pay every month to play a game they paid $60 to buy in the first place (shakes head) oh well.

Now, were the game re-released for sale then I'm sure those downloads would be shut down. However untill then..

moo
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi again,

Thanks for the advice people, much appreciated.

I used to own the games many years ago, but as I say I threw them away eventually. In particular I remember my DM amiga disk had stopped working anyway, due to the aging process it had died a death.

I'll have a quick look to see if I can buy them at a low cost, it'll make me feel better :)

Cheers
Oid
User avatar
beowuuf
Archmastiff
Posts: 20687
Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2000 2:00 pm
Location: Basingstoke, UK

Post by beowuuf »

As analternative to DM/CSB you can also download either CSBwin or RTC, or both! : )
User avatar
cowsmanaut
Moo Master
Posts: 4378
Joined: Fri Jun 30, 2000 12:53 am
Location: canada

Post by cowsmanaut »

yes the clones are re-written and free for download. and they work better under windows anyway.

moo
User avatar
Des
Um Master
Posts: 461
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2003 11:58 pm
Location: Southampton, UK

Post by Des »

Copyright of old games is a funny business. I recently picked up issue 3 of "Retro Gamer" which featured on its coverdisc the entire Gremlin back-catalogue. The mag only gives out games where the copyright owners have given permission, and possible production of new versions is the main reason for refusal. For example the Ultimate games (some of the best ever on the Speccy and C64) have been excluded - Rare Games (which took over Ultimate) have just released a version of Sabre Wulf for the Gameboy.

Best thing about the Retro Gamer disc was the comprehensive pile of emulators (with clear instructions) that shipped with it. Alas Gremlin only did a few really good games, and a lot of mediocre ones IMHO. Issue 1 had a really great cover disc - I missed it but I'm not paying 50 GBP on eBay for a copy, given that...

... you can download almost any old game off the net at sites like bhlegend and underdogs, so as has been previously stated, it all depends on whether the copyright owner gives a hoot. I don't think George Gilbert and Paul Stevens are shaking in their boots. Actually, "clones" might be an interesting topic for Retro Gamer and/or an article on DM...?
User avatar
Jardice
Artisan
Posts: 185
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 7:36 am
Location: USA

Post by Jardice »

But then there's also the problem of some compaines that do.....but then don't keep their word or re-release their product knowing(or not) the fact that it has a high chance of not working.

I never heard of the "Retro Gaming" magazine though. Is it a european magazinge or it it just hard to find in the USA?
Meaningless quote:
Words cannot have meaning unless they're given a meaning, words cannot benifit or harm unless they are allowed to.
User avatar
Des
Um Master
Posts: 461
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2003 11:58 pm
Location: Southampton, UK

Post by Des »

Retro Gamer magazine is only sold in the UK, Australia and New Zealand.

Website at http://www.retrogamer.net

The publishers underestimated the demand for their mag and as a result the first two issues are hot property on eBay at the moment.
User avatar
Sandman
Apprentice
Posts: 40
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 12:48 pm
Location: Bratislava, Slovakia

Post by Sandman »

This really sux! Des, you have some luck living in UK. Such magazine must be an eden for someone like me... but 50 pounds is really a price :shock:
I see abandonware as a good choice, though (especially underdogs and bhlegend). Games you can get there are very often totally lost and yet unsupported by the companies which released them. Often these companies don't exist now or they have been consumed by a greater corp., so they cannot support users of their games. And for me it's better option to download a game for free rather than paying for it to someone who will use the money for himself. It's not pirating in a raw form, when companies lose their money. In this point I agree with cowsmanaut. Wasting money on eBay is not worth the box and paper manual :wink: . And in this case (DM) - I consider FTL a dead company (a great loss :cry: ), so you can sleep easily I think...
creating balance since 1987
User avatar
beowuuf
Archmastiff
Posts: 20687
Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2000 2:00 pm
Location: Basingstoke, UK

Post by beowuuf »

FTL may be dead but the people with the copyright are still around, so I think it's always good to be a little respectful of the copyright issues still
User avatar
Sandman
Apprentice
Posts: 40
Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 12:48 pm
Location: Bratislava, Slovakia

Post by Sandman »

Being respectful is right, but if you haven't got any other choice, using abandonware is not such crime IMHO... Games offered there are really old and often out of reach now.
creating balance since 1987
Post Reply