Then why is it that Venus is hotter then Mercury? No it's more then just distance form sun that determines the heat of Venus, its the 98% CO2 atmosphere that does that. The heat enters and can't escape so Venus just keeps getting hotter and hotter, in a self perpetuating greenhouse effect.Chaos-Shaman wrote:"If you don't believe the experts about what CO2 in the atmosphere does to planetary temperatures just take a look at Venus. It's about the same size as Earth. It's about the same Mass as Earth."
that's not a good example though SU, we're nothing like Venus. if Venus was in our orbit, it'd be like the earth.
Also, if distance from the sun was the only major determinant of temperature and climate, then why is it that the average surface temperature of the moon is -30 Celsius? The moon is the same distance from the sun as Earth is, it is the Earth's moon after all.
I think you might have missed this part of my post:
In other words, between Venus and Mercury, the cooler planet is Mercury, which is the closest planet to the sun, so if distance from sun is the determinant for temperature and climate, and not atmospere, then how it this? How can a planet further from the sun be hotter then a planet closer to the sun? Explain that, because it does not make any sense to me unless atmospheric composition does play a major role.Yet average surface temperatures on Venus are about 480 degrees (hotter even then Mercury average surface temperatures of 166.86 degrees, which is much, much closer to the sun then Venus is)
Ask any astronomer, chemist, physicist, geologist, meteorologist, or climatologist about this and they will all give you the same answer, atmosphere does play a huge role in planetary weather and climate.
Ask any of the above why Venus is so much hotter, on average, then Mercury and you'll get the same answer, greenhouse effect, Venus has a thick atmosphere that's mostly greenhouse gasses that traps the heat, whereas Mercury's atmosphere is very thin so it provide very little protection from gaining or losing heat.
Here's the data on a few websites for interested readers to look up for themselves:
http://www.digipac.ca/chemical/mtom/con ... sfacts.htm has a comparison of earth, the moon, and mars
http://solarsystem.nasa.gov/planets/com ... ect1=VenusThis is a great site, you can compare any 2 planets in our solar system to each other.
http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space ... d_to_Earthcomparison of earth and venus
http://planets.findthedata.org/compare/ ... y-vs-Venushere's another good site for comparing 2 planets and seeing their statistics.
http://planets.findthedata.org/compare/ ... th-vs-Marshere's a comparison of the 4 rocky planets (Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars), using the site above.